Runners-Up

Spider-Man 2

Votes: 5
Website | OpenCritic: 90 (97% recommend) | Playstation

#11
Lies of P

Votes: 5
Website | OpenCritic: 82 (88% recommend) | Discuss
Steam | Microsoft | Other Stores
Show 1 Reviews

<
#10
Reviews of Lies of P:
Kryzn, Knight of the Salt Mines
A surprisingly competent souls-like, that despite the Initial silly hook even has some pretty decent lore and story. Just enough innovation in the combat system to make it a bit new and interesting, and the boss fights are spectacular. Levels are not as good as DS, but the simplicity is helpful.
Cyberpunk 2077: Phantom Liberty

Votes: 5
Website | OpenCritic: 89 (98% recommend) | Discuss
GOG | Steam | Other Stores

#9
Slay the Spire Splay the Sire

Votes: 5
Website | OpenCritic: 89 (100% recommend) | Discuss
Steam | Humble
Show 1 Review

#8
Reviews of Slay the Spire:
tjhowse
It's Slay the Spire.
Shadows of Doubt

Votes: 5
Website
Steam
Show 1 Review

#7
Dredge

Votes: 5
Website | OpenCritic: 82 (90% recommend)
Steam | GOG

#6
Reviews of Shadows of Doubt:
tjhowse
Janky as hell but deliciously ambitious. Best way to simulate hiding in a man's bathroom to scan fingerprints off his toilet.
Resident Evil 4 Resident Evil 4 (2023) Would You Prefer
Re-Resident Evil 4?

Votes: 6
Website | OpenCritic: 92 (98% recommend)
Steam | Xbox | Playstation
Show 1 Review

#5
Cyberpunk 2077 Now It's Cyberpunk 2080

Votes: 6
Website | OpenCritic: 76 (63% recommend) | Discuss
GOG | Steam | Other Stores

#4
Reviews of Resident Evil 4:
Fysi
Twas a great game on the GameCube, and Capcom have brought it out of the past while still retaining its soul and charm.
Vampire Survivors

Votes: 7
Website | OpenCritic: 87 (100% recommend)
Discuss
Steam
Show 1 Review

#3
Super Mario Bros. Wonder

Votes: 7
Website | OpenCritic: 91 (98% recommend)
Nintendo Store
Show 3 Reviews

#2
Reviews of Vampire Survivors:
Fysi
If you've played it for more than 20 minutes, you know why this is here. If you've not played it for more than 20 minutes, what are you doing? Go play it! The most generous and best pound per hour of entertainment ever.
Reviews of Super Mario Bros. Wonder:
Noel
A wonderful gem of creative genius from the Nintendo team - it remained fresh and joyful during the whole time. Basically, this game feels like all the good ideas that were cut from the previous several milquetoast 2D Mario games.
megapenthes
Great 2d platforming, very tight. Fun psychedelic bits.
QuantumJump
It's rare that a mainline Mario game is less than stellar, and this game absolutely keeps that streak going. It's fun, it's polished, the controls are tight, the wonder mechanic is joyful, if weird. Another home run from Nintendo. 8/10
Dave the Diver Dave the Driver Drave the Diver Drave the Driver

Votes: 9
Website | OpenCritic: 90 (100% recommend)
Steam | Switch
Show 2 Reviews

#1
Reviews of Dave the Diver:
Ox
Is it an indie tho? Maybe not, but this was a delightful smaller game between behemoth releases that wormed its way into my heart. Starts out as something that seems light and forgettable, but smartly layers systems and hooks until you end up with a surprisingly deep and quite special game.
veerserif
My maximalist joy of the summer, Dave The Diver is an incredibly silly game that never saw a minigame it didn't like. It absolutely revels in how much more it can pile on, and I have a soft spot for knowingly unserious games. Bancho is the greatest.


The Best Games of 2023

#10
Lethal Company
Game of the Year Votes: 1
Runner-Up Votes: 5
Reviews: 2
Official Discord Server
Steam
Morgan?!
The perfect "throw a bunch of problems into a pot and see what happens" experience. So many potential interactions and situations out of such a simple setup mean this game never gets old with the right group of friends.
megapenthes
I played a few times with scrub friends, then once with 2/3 scrub friends and 1/1 expert friend of scrub. I still treasure the moment when, because I was dead, I heard the expert say, exasperated "I can't believe this fucking crew". & the time I found a log on the company planet and proudly told him
#9
Against the Storm
Game of the Year Votes: 1
Runner-Up Votes: 5
Reviews: 2
Website
OpenCritic: 92 (92% recommend)
Steam | Epic
Ringwraith
What if the most interesting part of city builders was the only part? The puzzle of constantly having to adapt to random conditions and even building selection. Extremely smartly designed how every system feeds into each other so you can pull off big comebacks. Then harder settings change one thing.
Kryzn, Knight of the Salt Mines
Randomized city building with rogue like elements means I get to play the fun bit of restarting a new colony over and over and over. The randomization makes it just different enough to always be interesting. Just wish I could remember all the possible production chains.
#8
The Talos Principle 2
Game of the Year Votes: 2
Runner-Up Votes: 1
Reviews: 2
Website
OpenCritic: 89 (98% recommend)
Steam | Epic | Xbox | Playstation
Avagad
The Talos Principle games continue the great 3D puzzle legacy started by Portal. TP2 doesn't quite reach the same heights as TP1 but is still one of the best puzzle games of this year
LW
The philosophy might have been lower-level, but it was carried through by endearing characters. Also the puzzles were pretty good.
#7
Cocoon
Game of the Year Votes: 2
Runner-Up Votes: 8
Reviews: 2
Website
OpenCritic: 87 (98% recommend)
Steam
Ox
Of all the great indie puzzles I played last year, this was probably the best - it's an awesome, mind-bendy, trippy experience full of those great "I'm a genius!"moments. However I'll use this review to tell you to ALSO go play Chants of Sennaar, The Case of the Golden Idol, and Jusant! yay, indies!
LW
An exceptionally smooth game that kept me going just to see what weird bio-wonders it would come up with next, and balanced the puzzles just right.
#6
Remnant 2
Game of the Year Votes: 3
Runner-Up Votes: 1
Website
OpenCritic: 82 (86% recommend)
Steam | Epic | Playstation | Xbox
#5
Shadow Gambit: The Cursed Crew
Game of the Year Votes: 3
Runner-Up Votes: 2
Website
OpenCritic: 85 (93% recommend)
Official Store | Steam
#4
Armored Core VI: Fires Of Rubicon Armoured Core VI: Fires Of Rubicon
Game of the Year Votes: 4
Runner-Up Votes: 9
Reviews: 4
Website
OpenCritic: 85 (90% recommend)
Steam | Other Platforms
Ox
FromSoft don't miss. I had no idea what to expect going in, and videos of other people playing looked completely incomprehensible - until I hopped in myself and found an incredible, fluid, dare I say intuitive action-shooting-fighty game. The Zimmerman is maybe my favourite gun in video games.
Ringwraith
Wrings incredible character out of a faceless cast who only exist as words on the radio. Lets you pretty make pretty much any mech you want provided you know how to pilot it well enough. Swords rule. Incredible sound design, very good computer voice alerts. Everything is Actual Size, which is big.
QuantumJump
After finally getting FROM games last year with Elden Ring, and loving mechs, I was very excited for AC6. It didn't disappoint. The customisation of your mech is unlike anything I've experienced, and the buildcraft allows bringing down the difficulty when needed (Zimmermans my beloved). 8/10
Morgan?!
Genuinely the best action game to come out in a while. I've never felt cooler when committing horrific acts of mass violence.
#3
Alan Wake 2
Game of the Year Votes: 6
Runner-Up Votes: 3
Reviews: 4 | Discuss
Website
OpenCritic: 89 (93% recommend)
Epic | Playstation | Xbox
Kane
Alan Wake 2 is fearlessly and joyfully unique and charmingly indulgent, and filled with peerless visual spectacle unlike anything you'll see any any other game—until Remedy's next masterpiece. The whole medium is ennobled by their creativity and evident love for their art. An absolute triumph.
mrwonko
🎶 Champion of light…🎵Herald of darkness.
What a gorgeous game. The lighting is something else.
And exactly the kind of meta nonsense I'm into.
Teambo
A little condensed autumn spookyness. The vibes are on point.
Fysi
And now, we sing.
#2
The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom
Game of the Year Votes: 6
Runner-Up Votes: 20
Reviews: 11
Website
OpenCritic: 96 (97% recommend)
Official Store
Noel
For the Ultrahand alone, this makes my list of top games of the year. Despite being not super impressed by the exploration of the overworld, I found myself having a great time playing this through - once I stopped wanting it to be Breath of the Wild.
Ox
The madmen at nintendo somehow figured out how to make a perfect game better. I have no idea how they made this or how it runs on Switch. The new powers are awesome, the world is huge and full of fun stuff to do. A miracle of game systems design. Would have been my GOTY any other year.
veerserif
Between the BG3 versus TOTK titan fight, this is where I land. Sorry BG3! You're lovely too! It's just that my brain's D&D space is already occupied! I loved TOTK's new ways to engage with the space, loved its contraptions, and also it let me build a combine harvester with swords, planks and hot glue.
Ranneko
The only AAA game I was able to find time to play through this year. There is always something to do, it felt like no matter how small a time I could steal to play I could make some sort of progress it stayed running on my Steam Deck for several months straight
Douchetoevsky
Nintendo really understands that video games are about play in a way that few other large developers seem to get. Just a joy to puzzle out how to use all the toys they give you in TotK.
Dr. Khelzor
Had my 2008-excited-for-Banjo-Kazooie-Nuts-&-Bolts-self played this game played this, it would probably be my favorite game of all time. Alas, I approached this game with the grim Akira-biked efficiency of a man with a day job. I'm sorry Nintendo, you didn't deserve this.
Gwathdring
I loved Breath of the Wild but had a few reservations. Tears of the Kingdom resolves most of them indirectly, largely by plastering more more into a AAA sequel than I've seen before. More to explore, more feels, more strapping rockets to hammers, and more shield surfing. 13/10
QuantumJump
I'm surprised by this; I didn't like Breath of the Wild at all. But tears of the kingdom takes almost everything I found disappointing about BotW and makes it incredible. The story is moving, the dungeon and shrine design is fantastic, the emergent gameplay is hilarious and engaging. 9/10
Avagad
An incredible follow-up to one of the greatest games of all time. Taking advantage of the familiarity players have for the first game and using it to enhance the sequel
Tyen
Lightening does strike twice
velleic
Not as good as BOTW, is my hot take. Still really great though.
#1
Baldur's Gate 3
Game of the Year Votes: 32
Runner-Up Votes: 25
Reviews: 12 | Discuss
Website
OpenCritic: 96 (99% recommend)
Steam | Playstation | Xbox
Fredurix
After having Baldur's Gate 3 consume the last half of my gaming year and impeding my minature painting progress even more than usually, I have to restrain the urge to start a new game as a power-hungry dark urge sorcerer. I think that says it all. It's just that good.
Kane
The modern successor to the classic cRPG that RPG fans have been waiting for, BG3 somehow manages to be more ambitious in its writing and level and quest design than previous revivals like Pillars and Torment while still being accessibly modern and cinematic. It's everything I could have asked for.
Noel
It's the obvious choice, and the right one. A brilliant CRPG that actually got me to play a CRPG, mostly by being based in a combat system I was already familiar with. I have barely even started Act 3, and it's still the winner.
Fysi
Was my GOTY until I got to that section in AW2. If I were more a sandbox guy, I would suspect this would pip AW2 if I had more time this year to play this fully.
Spad 😬
As close are you're going to get to the experience of playing D&D 5e on your computer (including all the awkward sex roleplay), and let's face it you're never going to schedule that tabletop game, you're just not, stop kidding yourself.
Morgan?!
Karlach told me she believes in me and now I can do anything.
Avagad
You can have sex with a bear
Ox
I won't say it's "a ttrpg on pc" because it's not - it's its own incredible thing. Gives you a world you want to inhabit, and lets you affect it in more ways than you can imagine. I also haven't seen a cast of characters get people down bad like this since Hades. Now I just need to finish it...
mrwonko
30 hours in I already love it. Always happy when I can do weird shit and fail forward.
Jammy
nearly as good as neverwinter nights
Fiyenyaa
Disclaimer: I have not finished it. But it is such an incredible CRPG achievement that I have no choice but to stan. Interesting characters and great performances, my only criticism is that it should be using 4e mechanics
Teambo
At best, this feels like a D&D TTRPG session with a strict RAW DM. At it's other best it's a dating sim. ❤ Lae'zel. Single-handedly bringing the CRPG genre to the masses and it critically succeeds at that.


Honourable Mentions

Strong contenders that just didn't make it into the top 20.
(Click underlined items to see reviews.)
BattleBit Remastered
Cobalt Core
Counter-Strike 2
Dota 2
Hi-Fi Rush
Jusant
Marvel's Midnight Suns
Starfield
Warhammer 40,000: Darktide
Citizen Sleeper
Dawncaster
Diablo IV
Final Fantasy XVI
Hitman World of Assassination
Honkai: Star Rail
Pentiment
Star Wars Jedi: Survivor
Street Fighter 6
The Case of the Golden Idol
13 Sentinels: Aegis Rim
Aliens: Dark Descent
Arma 3
Brotato
Cassette Beasts
Chained Echoes
Chants of Sennaar
Cities: Skylines II
Coffee Talk
Coral Island
Cult of the Lamb
Darkest Dungeon II
Dead by Daylight
Deep Rock Galactic
Demon's Souls
Dwarf Fortress
Elden Ring
Factorio
God of War (2018)
Hades
Horizon Zero Dawn
Hunt: Showdown
Jagged Alliance 3
Marvel's Guardians of the Galaxy
Marvel's Spider-Man: Miles Morales
Mechabellum
Metal Gear Solid
Minecraft
Moonring
PlateUp!
Pokémon GO
Risk of Rain Returns
Sea of Stars
Signalis
Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order
Stray
The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild
Timberborn
Titanfall 2
Tunic
Victoria 3
Warhammer 40,000: Rogue Trader


Special Consideration

Wonderful games recommended by just one member of the community.
Titles in bold were that member's Game of the Year!
(Click underlined items to see reviews.)
Aeon Trespass: Odyssey
Amnesia: The Bunker
Bean and Nothingness
Bobo the Cat
Can of Wormholes
Cruelty Squad
Disco Elysium: The Final Cut
Dominions 5 - Warriors of the Faith
Dyson Sphere Program
Fallout: New Vegas
Fire Emblem: Three Houses
Frosthaven
Hearts of Iron IV: Kaiserreich
In the Groove
Marvel Snap
Mundaun
Nuclear Option
OTXO
Persona 5 Royal
Pokémon Unite
Prey
Project Zomboid
Runescape
Stardew Valley
Super Auto Pets
The Texas Chain Saw Massacre
The Zachtronics Solitaire Collection
Thief: The Black Parade
Trials of Fire
Venba
Void Stranger
Xenoblade Chronicles 3: Expansion Pass Wave 4 - Future Redeemed
Age of Empires II: Definitive Edition
A Mortician's Tale
ASTLIBRA Revision
Backpack Battles
BattleTech
Bayonetta 3
Blasphemous 2
Bloodborne
Bomb Rush Cyberfunk
Caves of Qud
Citra
Conquest of Elysium 5
Crab Champions
Dangeresque: The Roomisode Triungulate
DCS World
Deadeye Deepfake Simulacrum
Dead Space
Deathloop
Death Must Die
Devil May Cry 5
Dishonored 2
Dragon Age: Inquisition
Dragon Dreams: A Taste of Adventure
Dread Templar
Dune: Imperium
eFootball 2023
Elsinore
Erannorth Chronicles
Escape From Lavender Island
Escape from Tarkov
Europa Universalis IV
Everspace 2
Fate/hollow ataraxia
Fear & Hunger 2: Termina
Fights in Tight Spaces
Final Fantasy V (Pixel Remaster)
Final Fantasy XIV: Endwalker
Fire Emblem Warriors: Three Hopes
Football Manager 2024
Forza Horizon 5
Forza Motorsport
Frog Detective 3: Corruption at Cowboy County
Ghost of Tsushima Director's Cut
Ghost Song
God of War Ragnarök
Gotham Knights
Grow Home
Guilty Gear Strive
Hearts of Iron IV: Old World Blues
Helldivers
Hellish Quart
Hell Let Loose
Heretic's Fork
Hexcells Infinite
Hitman: Freelancer
Hogwarts Legacy
Hole.io
HROT
Humanity
Hyper Demon
I Did Not Buy This Ticket
Immortality
Inscryption
Into the Breach
iRacing
Kingdom Come: Deliverance
Lab Cat
Levelhead
Life Is Strange: True Colors
Linelith
Lone Fungus
Magic: The Gathering Arena
Mars First Logistics
Mass Effect
Mass Effect 2
Mass Effect Legendary Edition
McPixel 3
MechWarrior Online
Metroid Dread
Metroid: Zero Mission
Mirror's Edge
Misericorde: Volume One
Monster Prom
Morroblivion
Mosa Lina
MyHouse.wad
My Work Is Not Yet Done
NEO: The World Ends with You
No Man's Sky
NORCO
Octopath Traveler II
OlliOlli World
Ooblets
Orb of Creation
Outward: Definitive Edition
Party Animals
Path of Exile
Patrick's Parabox
Pikmin 4
Pillars of Eternity II: Deadfire
Pineapple on pizza
Pistol Whip
Pizza Tower
Pokémon Scarlet and Violet
Potion Craft: Alchemist Simulator
Prestige Tree
Prime Mover
Psychonauts 2
Purrgatory
Quake
Quake II - Enhanced Edition
Queer Man Peering Into A Rock Pool.jpg
Rain World: Downpour
Ready or Not
Returnal
Return to Monkey Island
Reverse: 1999
Risk of Rain 2
Rogue Legacy 2
Rollerdrome
Roll Player Adventures
Sailing Era
SEASON: A letter to the future
Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice
Severed Steel
Shadows Over Loathing
Shogun Showdown
Slay the Princess
Spelunky 2
Spider-Man 2
Spider-Man: Miles Morales
Sporcle
Star Citizen
Star Wars Jedi Knight II: Jedi Outcast
Storyteller
Strange Horticulture
Stray Gods: The Roleplaying Musical
Subnautica: Below Zero
Super Woden GP 2
Symphony of War: The Nephilim Saga
Synth Riders
System Shock Remastered
Tchia
Tetris 99
Tetris Effect: Connected
The Banner Saga
The Cosmic Wheel Sisterhood
The Elder Scrolls II: Daggerfall
The Invincible
The Legend of Heroes: Trails into Reverie
The Outer Worlds
Thirsty Suitors
Tinykin
Tom Clancy's Rainbow Six Siege
Valheim
Vintage Story
Wanted: Dead
Warframe
Warhammer Fantasy Roleplay 2e
Wartales
We Who Are About To Die
What the Bat?
Wildermyth
Word Trails
World of Horror
World of Warcraft: Dragonflight
Yi Xian: The Cultivation Card Game
ZERO Sievert
ΔV: Rings of Saturn